Historian Don Rumbelow challenges Jack the Ripper DNA link to Kosminski

PUBLISHED: 11:03 10 September 2014 | UPDATED: 11:16 10 September 2014

Discovering Eddowes' body in Mitre Square, September 30, 1888... and (inset) historian Don Rumbelow

Discovering Eddowes' body in Mitre Square, September 30, 1888... and (inset) historian Don Rumbelow


A new claim this week that DNA has finally identified Jack the Ripper 126 years after the Whitechapel Murders has been challenged by a leading historian.

Catherine Eddowes... Ripper's 4th known victimCatherine Eddowes... Ripper's 4th known victim

Donald Rumbelow, author of several works on the Victorian serial killer who gouged the bodies of at least five prostitutes murdered in 1888, claims the time elapse is too long for the DNA to be accurate.

“There’s no weight in the DNA theory,” Rumbelow told the East London Advertiser. “The sample is taken from the shawl alleged to have belonged to Catherine Eddowes, one of the victims.

“But it was never on the detailed two-page list of her belongings found at the murder scene. There was never any mention of a shawl among the items.”

The DNA is said to match a descendant of one of the seven main suspects, a deranged 25-year-old Polish immigrant named Aaron Kosminski who lived in Whitechapel at the time, identified in a new book by historical sleuth Russell Edwards who bought the shawl seven years ago.

Mitre Square todayMitre Square today

Edwards claims semen stains on the shawl gave a DNA match to Kosminski’s descendant who he traced.

The shawl was said to have been kept as a gruesome souvenir by a constable at the scene in Mitre Square, Aldgate, on the night of September 30, 1888, and handed down through his descendants.

But the constable didn’t belong to the City of London Police. He was a Metropolitan Police officer stationed in Islington—five miles from Mitre Square, historian Rumbelow points out.

It was likely to have been handled by too many people down the years, including enthusiasts at a two-day Ripper convention held in Mile End last year where it was said to have been on display.

“The shawl would be heavily contaminated,” he added. “I don’t believe the shawl genuinely came from Eddowes.

“There is a problem of provenance about the chronology of the ownership or location of the shawl over the last 126 years.”

Catherine Eddowes, a 46-year-old prostitute living in Flower & Dean Street off Brick Lane, half-a-mile from where she was murdered, was one of two women butchered that night.

The latest theory about the killer is one of 100 that have emerged over the past century-and-a-quarter since the Whitechapel Murders which have named Kominski among a long line of suspects that have included American author Lewis Carroll—and even the Prince of Wales, long since discredited.

Latest East London News Stories


Housing and Communities minister Lord Bourne has been on a fact-finding visit to east London to see how the government’s Controlling Migration fund is being spent.


Emergency fire crews had to cut through the security door of a taxi repair garage under railway arches in Bethnal Green to remove propane gas cylinders in danger of exploding when a blaze broke out during the night.

Staff on the Central line are set to walk out for 24 hours the weekend before Christmas.


A giant canvas of historical photographs of figures in the 19th and 20th centuries was projected onto the façade of the old London Hospital building in Whitechapel to mark the 70th anniversary of the NHS.

Detectives have launched an investigation after a woman was raped in the basement of a building in Whitechapel.


Britain’s tallest rental apartment block has been topped out at Canary Wharf after reaching 60 storeys.

Yesterday, 16:00

Santa Claus is planning to zoom down the Thames on his modern-day speedboat sleigh to switch the Christmas lights on at the historic St Katharine Docks.

Yesterday, 14:00

Youngsters are starting the school day in Bethnal Green with a square meal paid for by a three-year funding deal from a parcel delivery depot.


Are you a landlord looking for a fixed rental income, paid whether the property is empty or not? Steve Westley, general manager at estate agents Elliot Leigh, explains their Guaranteed Rent Scheme and how it takes the stress out of letting your property.

Newsletter Sign Up

East London Advertiser twice-weekly newsletter
Sign up to receive our regular email newsletter

Our Privacy Policy

Most read news

Show Job Lists

Digital Edition


Enjoy the
Docklands and East London Advertiser
e-edition today


Education and Training


Read the
Education and Training
e-edition today

Read Now