Search

Citizens of Tower Hamlets have right to know if Mayor Rahman was properly elected, judge rules

07:00 08 September 2014

Mayor Lutfur Rahman

Mayor Lutfur Rahman

Archant

Embattled Tower Hamlets Mayor Lutfur Rahman is fighting a war on two fronts in the High Court over allegations of election fraud after a BBC Panorama programme and attempts to stop an audit of town hall accounts.

‘Eric Pickles pushed through audit’

Mayor Lutfur Rahman claimed Eric Pickles “forced through the audit decision just a day after new legislation making the Council pick up the bill”.

He went to the High Court to challenge “taxpayers’ money being spent on a politically-motivated campaign” triggered by a much-criticised BBC Panorama documentary”.

He also criticised the cost of the petition challenging his own election in May.

A spokesman for the mayor said: “The costs are met from his private budget, which is why the petitioners would have to pay his costs should they lose. The Mayor is confident the court will uphold the election as free and fair.”

A top judge thwarted his bid to stop a petition claiming election fraud in May going to trial, when he ruled “the citizens of Tower Hamlets have the right to know whether the Mayor was properly elected or not”.

Trade union activist Andrew Erlam, an election candidate who ran on an anti-corruption ticket, had petitioned the court under the 1983 Representation of the People’s Act, directly naming Mayor Rahman and the council’s election Returning Officer John Williams.

Judicial Commissioner Richard Mawrey, QC, ruled that it was not necessary to hold the oral hearing sought by the mayor who was challenging the petition.

“I do not intend to allow this petition to become bogged down in endless procedural wrangling between the parties,” Commissioner Mawrey said.

“The citizens of Tower Hamlets have the right to know whether the Mayor was properly elected or not.

“If he was, he has the right for this to be made clear — if he was not, the sooner the matter is rectified the better.”

Serious allegations of malpractice were made against the Returning Officer concerning “a schedule of ‘ghost’ voters which, whether true or false, reflect on the impartiality of his staff”.

But the judge was not ordering an election recount, since May’s polling had long passed.

“It is better to concentrate on the serious allegations of electoral malpractice raised by the petition,” he concluded.

Meanwhile, another High Court judge has rejected the mayor’s bid to halt a major audit of the council’s public spending which had been ordered by Communities Secretary Eric Pickles.

Tower Hamlets Tory Opposition leader Peter Golds said the two High Court rejections were “an extraordinary indictment of the management of the council”.

Cllr Golds told the East London Advertiser: “Twice in four days Rahman has been severely criticised by different High Court judges.

“This is yet another example of Rahman treating the taxpayer as a personal piggy bank for his own ego.”

The Town Hall had sought a judicial review in July to challenge the motive for the audit following allegations of “fraud and financial mismanagement”.

But Judge Kenneth Parker threw out the Mayor’s application on Friday as “hopeless”.

The judge said: “Where concerns have been raised that a local authority is poorly governed, poorly managed financially and may even have engaged in fraud, there must be concerns as to whether such an authority has exercised its functions as economically, efficiently and effectively as could properly have been expected. The contrary is simply not arguable.

“The defendant (Mr Pickles) was plainly entitled to exercise his common law power to ask an expert body (accountants Pricewaterhouse-Coopers) to assist him by providing advice on any aspect of public affairs that was of potential concern to him.”

Legislation which makes the local authority pick up the tabs for a Government-ordered audit came into effect on April 3, a day before Mr Pickles sent in the auditors.

The judge said: “The council allowed the inspector to carry out an investigation for a substantial period, at public expense, before launching its belated challenge and asking months later for the decision to be quashed.”

The council is now seeking an oral hearing, it confirmed on Friday, in which its QC Jonathan Swift would challenge the motive for the audit, aiming to stop a full judicial review going ahead. The audit is thought to be costing £1 million — so far.

+++

Mayor accused at High Court of using ‘spiritual influence’ for re-election

Tower Hamlets goes to high court to challenge Pickles audit

Latest East London News Stories

Yesterday, 16:29
Appeal for witnesses who saw this man...

A man who sexually harassed a woman with her two young children in east London is being sought this week by police who have been trawling CCTV.

Yesterday, 13:08
Toddler hurt in traffic accident

A two-year-old toddler is fighting for his life today after being air-lifted 10 miles to the Royal London Hospital in Whitechapel following a road accident.

Fri, 23:52
Thefts from fire-stations end in jail for raiders

The last of three thieving conspirators who broke into fire-stations stealing emergency equipment to smuggle abroad for cash has been sentenced today.

Fri, 14:29
.Luthur Edwards... died after being stabbed outside York Hall

Detectives investigating the murder of Luther Edwards on the steps of east London’s York Hall have made a fifth arrest, Scotland Yard has just confirmed.

Thu, 21:58
Bethnal Green's Morpeth Secondary [Google image]

Any confusion over the change in the way schools’ performances are now assessed with today’s GCSE results hasn’t stopped Bethnal Green’s Morpeth Secondary reaching for the stars.

Wed, 16:34
The 'stink' hole just yards from houses next to former Phoenix smelting works site

A woman with cancer and a 10-month-old baby girl are among hundreds of people hit by fumes from contaminated canalside land in London’s East End where a wartime smelting works once stood.

Tue, 14:33
Dr Claire Sheppey and her burned-out top-floor flat in north London

A hero doctor from the 2005 Aldgate terrorist Underground train bombing 11 years ago died after discarding a cigarette in a plastic bag causing a fire in her top-floor flat, an inquest heard today.

Tue, 13:10
'Mini Manhattan' as City Island will appear on a loop of the River Lea

The first batch of 100 new apartments put on the market at the new ‘Mini Manhattan’ London City Island complex under construction on the Leamouth Peninsula in east London has been snapped up.

Newsletter Sign Up

Most read news

HOT JOBS

Show Job Lists

Competitions

You could win £15,000 to spend on either their mortgage or a deposit towards the home of their dreams

Wouldn’t it be lovely to have a period of time when you simply don’t have to worry about finding the money each month to pay your mortgage? When you don’t have to put money aside from your monthly income, or worry about having to afford other essential outgoings?

Which book character do you share cleaning habits with?

Whether you have more in common with put-upon Cinderella, emotionally turbulent Jane Eyre, or easily distracted Mole, you’re sure to appreciate that one lucky winner will receive four sessions of free cleaning. Enter our quiz for your chance to win. All runners up will get £10 off their first clean when making a repeat booking.

Digital Edition

cover

Enjoy the
Docklands and East London Advertiser
e-edition today

Subscribe

Education and Training

cover

Read the
Education and Training
e-edition today

Read Now