‘Failed benefit experiment pushes people into problem debt’

PUBLISHED: 07:00 14 September 2018

Sam Crosby from Toynbee Hall. Pic: WAIS ALI

Sam Crosby from Toynbee Hall. Pic: WAIS ALI


The universal credit benefit experiment is pushing people into problem debt.

Phil Andrew, chief executive at StepChange. Pic: StepChange Debt CharityPhil Andrew, chief executive at StepChange. Pic: StepChange Debt Charity

That is one view expressed after debt advice charity StepChange estimated it saw the highest average rent arrears of £1,944 among its clients living in Tower Hamlets compared to the other London boroughs.

Sam Crosby from Aldgate based charity Toynbee Hall, which advises people in the red, said: “Having a debt that threatens your home is incredibly stressful.

“For me, what needs to end is the universal credit experiment. It’s a failed experiment.”

The government rolled out universal credit in Tower Hamlets from February last year. It replaces six other benefits with a single monthly payment for people out of work or on low incomes.

But Mr Crosby said debt was built into the new benefit. Applicants had to wait six weeks before their first payment tipping them over into debt or seeing debts worsen, he said.

“Everyone who applies for it immediately puts themselves into six week rent arrears because of admin processes. It’s a vicious circle,” he said.

And Toynbee Hall has seen a shift in the kind of problems people seek help with from most wanting advice on credit card debt to more falling behind with rent, council tax or fuel bills.

StepChange boss Phil Andrew blamed higher housing costs for pushing residents into debt.

He called for more resources for advice and fairer debt collection so people facing financial trouble could make repayments they could afford.

Mr Crosby added that people were reluctant to engage with debt recovery when threatened with bailiffs knocking on their doors or the prospect of court appearances.

He recommended people seek advice from qualified professionals at the earliest opportunity.

“If you let something fester and grow, it makes it more difficult to get out of debt,” he said.

A spokesman from the Department for Work and Pensions said universal credit helped people into work faster and figures showed it satisfied most claimants. Councils had also received £200m to give claimants advice.

He said a seven day waiting period was scrapped and advance payments were available with extra housing support on offer.

Latest East London News Stories


Santa Claus is planning to zoom down the Thames on his modern-day speedboat sleigh to switch the Christmas lights on at the historic St Katharine Docks.


Youngsters are starting the school day in Bethnal Green with a square meal paid for by a three-year funding deal from a parcel delivery depot.


The 80th anniversary of the Kindertransport that rescued thousands of Jewish children escaping Nazi persecution in pre-war Germany is being marked by Tower Hamlets Council backing calls for government funding for similar operations in today’s conflict zones.


A Chrisp Street Market vendor is retiring after 54 years of trade.

Commuters are facing delays and cancellations this morning due to a signal failure on the TfL Rail line.

Yesterday, 20:12

Jews and Muslims in east London joined Britain’s biggest interfaith day of social action cooking 2,500 portions of kosher, halal, vegetarian and vegan soups at 20 events up and down the country.

Yesterday, 14:16

Education cutbacks are causing youngsters to miss learning about nature and healthy eating, according to one of East London’s oldest urban farms.

Yesterday, 12:30

A Limehouse charity led by young people wants to raise £42,500 to help save the city’s bees.


Are you a landlord looking for a fixed rental income, paid whether the property is empty or not? Steve Westley, general manager at estate agents Elliot Leigh, explains their Guaranteed Rent Scheme and how it takes the stress out of letting your property.

Newsletter Sign Up

East London Advertiser twice-weekly newsletter
Sign up to receive our regular email newsletter

Our Privacy Policy

Most read news

Show Job Lists

Digital Edition


Enjoy the
Docklands and East London Advertiser
e-edition today


Education and Training


Read the
Education and Training
e-edition today

Read Now