Hammers supporters want Freddie Piquionne and John Carew to be sold this month
West Ham fans discuss all things Hammers with our correspondent Nathaniel John.
Join in the discussion on Twitter @Nathaniel_John
This week, Hammers fans discuss whether the club should sell Freddie Piquionne and John Carew.
I would sell them both to bring in a couple of million to fund the signing of a decent striker or exchange them for a good forward.
@WHUFC_News
I would get rid of Piquionne but keep Carew, as he will make an impact from the bench.
@rossihammer78
They are both on massive wages for the Championship and are both useless.
@McGrath88
Carew has done very little so far. It only works when we play him in a 4-4-2 formation alongside Baldock. I think he might stay though, because of Cole’s lack of fitness. But in defence of both of them a lack of wingers doesn’t help. Carew looked better with Taylor on the wing.
@benny_berger
Carew started well but has gone off the boil. He has more to offer than Piquionne, who has been awful, but has played the majority of games this season stuck out wide. He’s not really had many chances up top. I would let him go, but probably keep Carew.
@TeeBeeEll
Both of them should be good enough to get goals at this level, but both have struggled with poor or no service. Neither of them should be sold unless they can be replaced. Carew is certainly worth keeping for the old Brian Deane option come the season’s end.
@niall_mcdonald
They should both be sold, definitely. They won’t cut it next season and aren’t delivering this year. We need more energy up front.
@ShaneBailey_ITF
I would let Piquionne go on a free transfer to anyone that wants him. I would be happy with Cole, Baldock, Sharp and Hall as our stirker.
@JimboNorwood
They both need to go, but I genuinely cannot see anyone who would take them!
@WhatFraserSaid
Sell them both, only if we can bring in a genuine goalscorer and then promote Nouble and Hall. The fans demand passion and desire, two things we don’t see from Carew or Piquionne.
@JohnnyMoncsNo16
Piquionne has been useless, and does nothing that Cole or Carew can’t do. We should sell him but keep Carew, as he was working well with Baldock before his injury.
@MJTweaton
I can’t help but think that both strikers’ poor form is to do with service and the team playing too narrow.
@youngy_315
Get shot of both, free some money up for wages.
@Holland_78
Comments: Our rules
We want our comments to be a lively and valuable part of our community - a place where readers can debate and engage with the most important local issues. The ability to comment on our stories is a privilege, not a right, however, and that privilege may be withdrawn if it is abused or misused.
Please report any comments that break our rules.
Read the rules here