Extinction Rebellion protesters spared jail over Canary Wharf glue stunt
PUBLISHED: 17:00 19 December 2019
(c) copyright citizenside.com
Three Extinction Rebellion protesters who glued themselves to a train have been spared jail.
Cathy Eastburn, 52, Mark Ovland, 36, and Luke Watson, 30, were each given a 12-month conditional discharge for halting Docklands Light Railway services at Canary Wharf station as part of a series of protests carried out across the capital.
The trio had denied the charges of obstructing an engine or a carriage using a railway on April 17 this year, claiming the stunt was justified because of the threat of climate change.
Extinction Rebellion (XR) say it is the first trial linked to the environmental demonstrations to be heard before a jury in a crown court, which has higher sentencing powers than a magistrates' court, where many other protesters have been dealt with.
Sentencing them at Inner London Crown Court on Thursday, Judge Silas Reid warned against protesting that would amount to them committing further criminal offences.
"Each of you planned these offences and were prepared to go to prison for committing them," he said.
"You each are clear that you did as you did to raise the alarm as to the dire situation you each believe the earth faces in respect of climate change.
"Your stated cause is to affect change in global attitudes to save the lives of most, if not all, of the human race.
"A cause intended to protect all human life is obviously a noble one."
The trio had maintained during the trial that their actions were not criminal, but Judge Reid said: "You broke the law and that means you are criminals.
"What's clear is that the rule of law is an essential part of society. It protects us all from anarchy and chaos."
You may also want to watch:
He told the defendants that he was concerned, with particular reference to Eastburn and Ovland, that they "may in fact decide to break the law again in the future for your cause", as the court heard that both defendants had been involved in other action carried out by XR.
The sentence means the trio could face prison if they commit another offence in the next 12 months.
Judge Reid added he was unable to give credit for a guilty plea or remorse, but acknowledged the trio had already spent time in custody on remand, which was eight days for Eastburn, 13 days for Watson and 53 for Ovland.
After one hour of deliberations, a jury unanimously found the defendants guilty on Wednesday (December 18), but the foreman added it was "with regret".
Watson, of The Street in Manuden, Essex, and Eastburn, of St Gerrards Close, Lambeth, both climbed on top of the train carriage and glued themselves to the roof, while Ovland, of High Street in Keinton Mandeville, Somerset, glued his hands to the side.
The trio were arrested during two weeks of demonstrations organised by XR which brought parts of the capital to a standstill.
Mother-of-two Eastburn was ordered to pay £1,166 in costs, while Watson and Ovland were ordered to pay £300 each.
Following the sentencing, musician Eastburn said: "I don't feel any remorse or regret for what I did, it was completely necessary to do that at that time."
Eastburn and Watson held a banner emblazoned with "climate emergency" as they stood on the train's roof, while Ovland held a sign which said he was super-glued alongside: "Do not pull me!"
Ovland, who has given up his job to protest against climate change, said: "Although we don't regret or feel any remorse for the action, we're still, as with every action, deeply apologetic to anyone affected.
"If there's any anger directed at us, maybe that should be directed to the inaction of the government."
During the trial, the trio said the disruption was kept to a minimum by targeting a station with multiple platforms so trains could be diverted through another platform.
But their actions were condemned by frustrated public transport users at the time who were forced to find alternative routes.