Bake Off fans question new mystery technical challenge

Fans are confused as to how fair the judging can be for the new technical challenge. <i>(Image: Channel 4)</i>
Fans are confused as to how fair the judging can be for the new technical challenge. (Image: Channel 4)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

The Great British Bake Off has introduced a brand new themed week to the show called Audience Choice Week.

All of the challenges have been suggested by the audience, with the signature challenge being a baked cheesecake the bakers had to make with a member of their family.

For the technical, the bakers were given a box of mystery ingredients and were asked to bake something of their choice using what they were given.

While the technical challenge is something viewers have never seen before, fans have been left confused and are all asking the exact same question.

Bake Off fans are all asking the same question about this technical challenge

Many fans of the show have taken to social media to ask the exact same question.

The viewers are confused as to how the judges Nigella Lawson and Paul Hollywood would be able to judge each bake fairly when everyone has done something different.

A few of the bakers played to their strengths, doing bakes like lemon drizzle cakes whereas others opted for more complex dishes.

One person said: “How are the judges going to compare totally different bakes?”

Another person said: “What is the point in a technical where everyone is making something different??

“The whole point is that they all make the same thing to show their technical ability??

“If they’re all different, how do you rate them!!!”

A third person said: “I’m not feeling the audience choice for this technical.

“I think they should all be baking the same thing.”

Other people are enjoying the new challenges, with one person saying: “The technicals this year are off the scale excellent, great to see something so different each week.”

Another person agreed and said: “This might be one of the best challenges I've seen in Bake Off.

“Literally just ‘Bake something’ – can't wait to see what they do.”

Where is the Great British Bake Off filmed?

The iconic white Bake Off tent is placed in Welford Park next to the country house while filming takes place.


Recommended reading

Fans of the Great British Bake Off are divided over new family challenge

Who was star baker during biscuit week of The Great British Bake Off 2026?

All the themed weeks for The Great British Bake Off - including a brand new addition


Filming for series in the past has also taken place at the Down Hall Hotel in Bishop’s Stortford, Valentines Mason in Redbridge, and Harptree Court in Somerset.

What did you think of the mystery technical challenge? Let us know in the comments.

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos