Search

West Ham’s hand stitch up is making VAR a farce

PUBLISHED: 12:30 15 January 2020

West Ham United's Robert Snodgrass (left) scores his sides first goal before VAR rules it as invalid during the Premier League match at Bramall Lane, Sheffield.

West Ham United's Robert Snodgrass (left) scores his sides first goal before VAR rules it as invalid during the Premier League match at Bramall Lane, Sheffield.

PA Wire/PA Images

Chanting VAR like Sheffield United fans did is not what this was brought in for

West Ham United's Sebastien Haller (centre) takes a shot on goal during the Premier League match at Bramall Lane, Sheffield.West Ham United's Sebastien Haller (centre) takes a shot on goal during the Premier League match at Bramall Lane, Sheffield.

For the second time this season, West Ham were denied a goal by a ridiculous handball decision, hand in hand with the farce that is VAR.

Last time it didn't matter. Michail Antonio's goal at Southampton would have made it 2-0, so the Hammers won anyway.

This time it mattered a great deal. A point at Bramall Lane against a decent Sheffield United would have kept David Moyes unbeaten since his return, instead his honeymoon period seems to be over.

I was all in favour of VAR when it was introduced. I remember some of the dreadful decisions that were inflicted upon the Hammers in previous years.

West Ham United manager David Moyes ahead of the Premier League match at Bramall Lane, Sheffield.West Ham United manager David Moyes ahead of the Premier League match at Bramall Lane, Sheffield.

Statistics suggest that if VAR decisions had gone their way, the Hammers would be in 13th place.

But this is a travesty, it is not how it was supposed to be. Someone kicking or heading the ball into someone's arm is not a foul and it never should be.

When the Sheffield United fans are chanting 'VAR' after a goal they never questioned is chalked off, then something is seriously wrong with the game.

I was at Brentford v QPR on Saturday and though there was a penalty shout that may have been corrected by VAR, at least I knew I could celebrate the goals without some faceless man not even in the stadium overturning it.

A general view of the big screen during the the VAR decision on West Ham United's Robert Snodgrass' (not pictured) goal during the Premier League match at Bramall Lane, Sheffield.A general view of the big screen during the the VAR decision on West Ham United's Robert Snodgrass' (not pictured) goal during the Premier League match at Bramall Lane, Sheffield.

In the end it was a bad night for the Hammers and not just because of the disallowed Robert Snodgrass goal.

This was a hugely disappointing display, especially in an attacking sense where Felipe Anderson, Sebastien Haller and Manuel Lanzini failed to impress.

Add to that the injury to Lukasz Fabianski, a recurrence of the one he suffered earlier in the season and the mistake by David Martin which cost the winning goal and it all adds up to something of a disaster.

In reality, West Ham did not start playing until Snodgrass came on as a second-half substitute.

Straight away his free kicks put the Blades under pressure suggesting he should have played from the start, while Pablo Fornals, the other man in form, was left on the bench for 84 minutes.

Those were both Moyes mistakes, while playing Aaron Cresswell in central defence, just as he did the last time he was in charge, may well be another one.

The manager, though, was fairly happy with the display.

"First of all, I'd like to say how well I thought my players played," he said. "I thought they were terrific and I'd say we didn't deserve to lose and we might even have been disappointed to have drawn in the end.

"I think if we had come here and taken a draw, we'd have been happy because it is such a tough place to come to."

The biggest talking point was that disallowed goal, which has been reverberating ever since it happened.

"I thought we scored a good goal to equalise," said Moyes. "I'm a football man and I watch football and I thought Declan Rice did brilliantly well to break through the middle with good power and strength.

"I think it's a really good goal and for that to happen from my point of view it's not right."

It isn't right and it is about time it was stopped, but as long as pundits like Gary Neville continue to support it by saying they are the rules, deal with it, then this game is surely doomed.

Nobody wants this farce, so why do we still have it in the best league in the world?


If you value what this story gives you, please consider supporting the East London Advertiser. Click the link in the orange box below for details.

Latest East London Sports News

Yesterday, 19:29

England have named a 13-man squad for their long-awaited return to Test cricket against the West Indies next week, preferring Joe Denly to the uncapped Dan Lawrence and confirming Dom Bess as number one spinner.

Yesterday, 19:05

London Lions are looking forward to playing in basketball’s Champions League next season.

Fri, 19:06

Recreational cricket is set to resume next weekend after Prime Minister Boris Johnson appeared to back-track on his earlier claim that issues surrounding communal teas and dressing rooms made the sport unsafe.

Fri, 18:54

British Olympic and Paralympic sports governing bodies have been given assurances over their short and longer-term financial future.

Fri, 18:46

England’s final preparations for the long-awaited return of Test cricket were boosted on and off the field on Friday, with Sam Curran testing negative for Covid-19 and a handful of key batsmen spending important time at the crease.

Fri, 17:32

Premiership Rugby clubs can return to contact training on Monday in “significant milestone” towards the league’s planned resumption on August 15.

Fri, 15:41

David Moyes has saluted Steve Bruce for the “incredible” job he has done at Newcastle.

Fri, 15:30

Following a £7million investment towards preparing the country’s football pitches, the Premier League, The FA and the Government, through Sport England, are making a further £2.19million available through their Football Foundation to help clubs return to football.

PROMOTED CONTENT

The NHS Test and Trace service brings together testing, contact tracing and outbreak management into an end-to-end service to stop the spread of the virus and help us move out of lockdown.

The UK Government has launched a campaign to shine a light on businesses and employees across the country who have responded to the impact of the Covid-19 pandemic in remarkable ways and are now going back to business.

Veterans are providing vital skills across a range of projects to help the country tackle the current coronavirus outbreak. From helping to build Nightingale Hospitals to delivering essential supplies to those who are shielding, they have helped thousands of people across the country. We take a look at how one such veteran is helping out.

Most read sport

Digital Edition

cover

Enjoy the
Docklands and East London Advertiser
e-edition today

Subscribe

Education and Training

cover

Read the
Education and Training
e-edition today

Read Now

Most Read

Latest from the East London Advertiser